A pair of reading glasses resting on a soft blush knit blanket, as if someone just finished reading

Imagine a managing partner you’ve known for years recommends your firm to a colleague over lunch. “You should call them,” she says. It’s the kind of introduction no advertising budget can buy.

Before that colleague picks up the phone, she does what careful buyers do. She looks you up.

The website still lists the services you offered three years ago. The team page is missing the two people you hired in the spring. The most recent article mentions a conference most of your clients have already forgotten. Nothing she finds is wrong, exactly. It’s simply old. And she has no way of knowing that your firm is busier and better than it has ever been.

This is the second article in our November series, Consistency Creates Confidence. Last week we looked at the quiet season nobody schedules. This week, we follow a single referral and see what that quiet season costs.

A referral arrives carrying someone else’s trust. Your online presence decides whether that trust survives the search.

The introduction

A referral is the warmest lead an established business receives. Someone the prospect already trusts has vouched for you, and much of the persuading has been done before you know the conversation exists.

But a referral is also a promise someone else made on your behalf. The prospect arrives expecting to confirm it. In the few minutes she spends with your website, your journal and your LinkedIn page, she is checking whether what she was told matches what she can see.

When it does, the call that follows feels easy. When it doesn’t, the trust she borrowed starts to thin.

Five places a referral looks

Most careful buyers follow a similar path, whether they realize it or not:

  • Your home page. Does it describe the business she was told about, in words she recognizes?
  • Your services. Is the work she needs clearly named, or does she have to guess?
  • Your team page. Can she see who she would actually be speaking with?
  • Your journal. When did you last publish something, and does it sound like the firm she heard about?
  • Your LinkedIn page. Is anyone home?

None of these needs to be perfect. Each one only needs to look current and sound like you. A stale date in any of them doesn’t prove anything is wrong. It simply leaves a question in the mind of someone who was ready to say yes.

The second name on the list

Think of a glowing letter of recommendation clipped to a résumé from five years ago. The letter is sincere. The person is excellent. But the reader can’t help wondering what happened in the years the résumé doesn’t mention.

That is what a strong referral paired with an outdated online presence feels like to a prospect. She may still call you. She may also call the second name on her list, the firm whose website looks as if someone is home.

You would never hear about it. That is what makes this kind of loss so hard to see.

No one emails to say they chose another firm because your team page was out of date. The referral simply never turns into a conversation, and the business assumes the timing wasn’t right.

The cost reaches existing clients too. I learned this as a customer, when I hired someone else for work that a contractor I already trusted could have done, simply because his website never said he did it. I share the full story in When Your Reputation Has Outgrown Your Website.

What consistency protects

Every referral carries two reputations: yours, and the reputation of the person who recommended you. When your online presence confirms what they said, both are strengthened. When it doesn’t, both are quietly spent.

Consistency is what keeps the two in step. A website, journal and LinkedIn page that are tended regularly don’t need to be elaborate. They need to be recent enough, and accurate enough, that a careful buyer finds the firm she was promised. Because so many of these moments happen when you’re not in the room, that steady record is doing more of the selling than most owners realize.

Next week, we’ll look at why marketing stalls in busy firms, and how deciding a year of subjects in advance keeps it moving.

Look yourself up

This takes about fifteen minutes. Try to do it as someone who has never met you.

Then put yourself in the prospect’s chair.

  1. Open a private browser window. Search for your firm’s name, then for your own.
  2. Open the first three results. Read each one as a stranger who has just been told you’re excellent.
  3. Write one sentence. Describe your firm the way a stranger would, based only on what you found.
  4. Compare it with what your best client would say. The distance between those two sentences is the work worth doing first.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Doesn’t a strong referral outweigh an outdated website?

Often it does. But a referral sets an expectation, and an outdated presence works against it at the exact moment the prospect is deciding whether to call. The stronger the recommendation, the more noticeable the gap can be.

What should we update first?

Start with whatever a referral is most likely to check: your home page, your services and your team page. Then add a recent article, so the record shows the business is active.

How often should we look ourselves up?

Once a quarter is a sensible rhythm for most established businesses, and always after a change in services, staff or direction.

Begin here

See what they see

It can be hard to read your own website as a stranger would. Send us your website address, and our team will send a candid first impression, written the way a referral would see it.

Send us your website →

Your Privacy Choices

We use analytics to understand how our website is used. When we advertise on platforms such as Facebook and Instagram, we may also use advertising tools that some state laws treat as targeted advertising or a sale of personal data. You can opt out of that here.

Read our Privacy Policy